Hillary Clinton agreed to turn over her private email server to
authorities on Tuesday, the same day an intelligence community inspector
general told congressional committees that at least five emails from the server
did contain classified information.
The decision to
hand over the server, as well as a thumb drive of all her work-related emails
to the Justice Department, represents an effort to blunt an expanding probe
into her use of a private email account.
Clinton, now the
Democratic presidential front-runner, "directed her team to give her email
server that was used during her tenure as (secretary of state) to the Department
of Justice, as well as a thumb drive containing copies of her emails already
provided to the State Department," her spokesman, Nick Merrill, told CNN
early Tuesday evening. "She pledged to cooperate with the government's
security inquiry, and if there are more questions, we will continue to address
them."
Merrill said in the meantime, Clinton's team "has worked
with the State Department to ensure her emails are stored in a safe and secure
manner."
The FBI, which
is handling the matter, declined to comment Tuesday evening. David E. Kendall,
Clinton's lawyer, did not immediately return messages seeking comment.
A senior Clinton
campaign aide said the server hadn't yet changed hands as of Tuesday evening
and Clinton's team is working with the Justice Department to arrange the
logistics of the handover. The thumb drive, meanwhile, has been turned over.
And Kendall, the aide said, has followed State Department guidance on
safekeeping.
Clinton's
campaign believes there are no emails from her State Department tenure on the
server, since it was wiped clean after she turned over her work-related emails
to the State Department, the aide said.
The aide said it's
the Clinton campaign's understanding that the Justice Department isn't looking
to reconstruct the server's history, but is instead concerned about the
security of the emails today, since some are now classified, though they
weren't classified or labeled as such at the time.
Boehner: 'It's about time'
For Clinton, the move -- which
Republicans like House Speaker John Boehner have urged for months -- indicates
her campaign sees a growing risk in the issue of her use of a private email
server, which has stoked concerns about her trustworthiness.
"It's about
time," Boehner said in a statement Tuesday night.
Since news broke
in March of her use of a personal email address on a server kept in her
Chappaqua, New York, home, Clinton has insisted that she's turned over all of
her work-related emails to the State Department and deleted all others -- but
wouldn't turn over her server to the government.
Clinton has been
dogged by poll numbers showing that more Americans, by a margin of about 20
percentage points, say she's not trustworthy rather than trustworthy. A late
July CNN/ORC poll found that 58% of all registered voters say it is extremely
important that the next president be honest and trustworthy.
Rep. Trey Gowdy,
who chairs the House Select Committee on Benghazi and has pushed for Clinton's
emails for months, claimed credit for her decision to turn over the server.
"The
revelation that Secretary Clinton exclusively used private email for official
public business, and the multitude of issues that emanated from her decision,
including this most recent one, demonstrates what can happen when Congress and
those equally committed to exposing the truth, doggedly pursue facts and follow
them," he said in a statement.
Senate Judiciary
Committee Chairman Chuck Grassley, R-Iowa, said Clinton waited "a long
time" before turning the server over.
"That's a
long time for top secret classified information to be held by an unauthorized
person outside of an approved, secure government facility," he said in a
statement. "I look forward to the FBI answering my questions so the
American people can be assured that everything has been done to protect our
national security interests and hold accountable anyone who broke the
rules."
Still, it's clear the GOP won't stop hitting Clinton on the
campaign trail, accusing her of secrecy over her decision to wait five months
to turn over the server.
Republican
National Committee Chairman Reince Priebus said in a statement Tuesday night
that releasing the server does little to answer questions about Clinton's
honesty.
"If Hillary
Clinton believed in honesty and transparency, she would have turned over her
secret server months ago to an independent arbiter, not as a last resort and to
the Obama Justice Department," he said. "Of course, if she really
cares about transparency, she would never have had a secret server in the first
place."
Classified emails
Clinton's decision to hand over the
server comes as the intelligence community's inspector general now says at
least five emails stored on Clinton's server contained classified information.
The documents were from a "limited sampling" of her emails and among
those 40 reviewed, said the inspector general, Charles McCullough III.
On Tuesday,
McCullough sent four of the emails to chairs of several congressional
committees. In a cover letter, he said two of the four emails included
information that has now been classified up to top secret.
One of the five
emails has since been declassified because it was no longer time-sensitive. The
intelligence community maintains the remaining two contained classified
material, but is deferring to the State Department on whether they should be
identified as such.
McCullough said
in the past that "none of the emails we reviewed had classification or
dissemination markings," but that some "should have been handled as
classified, appropriately marked, and transmitted via a secure network."
The State Department has told McCullough that "there are potentially
hundreds of classified emails within the approximately 30,000 provided by
former Secretary Clinton."
Republicans
shared exclusively with CNN Tuesday a review of those emails that the State
Department had released, which they said showed Clinton and her aides sent
information that would later be classified to six people's private email
addresses. They include former Deputy Secretary of State Bill Burns; Cheryl
Mills, who was Clinton's chief of staff at the State Department; and Jake
Sullivan, who served as Clinton's top foreign policy adviser. Clinton also
emailed information that would later be classified to close confidant Sidney
Blumenthal, whose communications with Clinton about Libya have become a focus
of the House committee investigating the 2012 Benghazi attacks.
"The fact that
classified information was sent to and from Hillary Clinton to at least six
separate individuals and potentially many more demonstrates just how big of a
risk her decision to use a secret server poses to our national security,"
Republican National Committee research director Raj Shah told CNN.
Widening probe
The probe into Clinton's email practices
has now expanded to include some of her top aides as part of a larger
investigation on the use of private email accounts by previous secretaries of
state. The Republican chairmen of three Senate committees -- intelligence,
homeland security and foreign relations -- sent a joint request in March for
both inspectors general to investigate the personal emails of Clinton's aides.
"We will
follow the facts wherever they lead, to include former aides and associates, as
appropriate," said Douglas Welty, a spokesman for the State Department's
inspector general.
In a July 17
letter to the State Department, Steve A. Linick, the State Department inspector
general, said his office is reviewing "the use of personal communications
hardware and software by five secretaries of state and their immediate
staffs." The Office of the Intelligence Community Inspector General is
assisting in the review.
One of the
emails containing since-classified information was released to the public,
prompting the intelligence community to ask the FBI to investigate the possible
compromise of classified material. The State Department now has a team of
analysts from the intelligence community to review Clinton's emails before any
more are released to the public.
Of the two
top-secret emails sent to Congress on Tuesday, State Department spokesman John
Kirby said they have not been released to the public and the department is
"taking steps to ensure the information is protected and stored
appropriately" while the determination was made.
"Department
employees circulated these emails on unclassified systems in 2009 and 2011, and
ultimately some were forwarded to Secretary Clinton," Kirby said.
"They were not marked as classified."
No comments:
Post a Comment